Italian Parliament Criminalizes Surrogacy Abroad: What You Need to Know
Table of contents
Italy Bans Surrogacy Abroad
On October 16, 2024, the Italian Parliament passed a controversial new law that criminalizes the use of surrogacy abroad. This move has sparked intense debate, particularly among Italian couples seeking alternative paths to parenthood and LGBT+ individuals hoping to start families. The law, which is part of a broader trend across Europe, has significant implications for people considering surrogacy in countries where it remains legal. For intended parents who are considering surrogacy, this change is crucial to understand. In this article, we will explore why this law was passed, what it means for Italian citizens, and how it affects surrogacy options for those seeking help from international surrogacy agencies like Anavara.
Why is Surrogacy Illegal in Italy?
Surrogacy has been illegal in Italy for many years. The law prohibits both commercial surrogacy (where a fee is paid to the surrogate mother) and altruistic surrogacy (where there is no financial compensation beyond basic medical and legal expenses). The Italian government has maintained that surrogacy undermines the concept of traditional family structures and that children should be born within natural biological processes. In addition to these beliefs, the country has struggled with low birth rates, and the government has seen the practice as a potential driver of exploitation, particularly for women from economically disadvantaged backgrounds.
However, many argue that the decision to become parents through surrogacy should be a personal one, particularly for couples facing infertility or same-sex couples who do not have easy access to other family-building methods.
The New Law: What Does It Mean for Italian Couples?
The new law passed by the Italian Parliament in October 2024 makes it illegal for Italian citizens to seek surrogacy services abroad. People who attempt to go abroad for surrogacy could face serious consequences, including jail terms and substantial fines. The law, which was signed by Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, seeks to clamp down on international surrogacy arrangements, citing concerns about the exploitation of women and the commodification of children.
Key Aspects of the Law:
- Criminal Penalties: Those who go abroad for surrogacy or help others do so can face up to two years in prison and fines of up to €1 million.
- International Impact: The law affects not only heterosexual couples but also same-sex couples looking to start families.
- Focus on Traditional Family Values: Supporters of the law argue that it protects traditional family structures and prevents Italy from becoming a destination for “surrogacy tourism.”
Why is Surrogacy Banned in Some European Countries?
Surrogacy remains a contentious issue in many European countries. The primary concern for opponents of surrogacy is the fear of exploitation, particularly of women who may be coerced into becoming surrogates due to financial hardship. Countries like Germany, France, and Spain have similar laws prohibiting the practice or limiting it in specific circumstances.
In Italy, surrogacy has been banned for years, but the latest law tightens the restrictions. Those in favor of surrogacy argue that if well-regulated, the practice can provide a much-needed opportunity for couples struggling with infertility. The law’s critics believe it unfairly targets vulnerable groups, particularly same-sex couples and people who cannot conceive through traditional means.
The Impact on LGBT+ Couples in Italy
Activists and human rights groups have raised concerns that this law disproportionately affects LGBT+ couples, especially gay men. In countries like Italy, where same-sex couples can access civil union since 2016, many gay couples turn to surrogacy as a way to become parents. With the new law, these couples face the possibility of being criminalized for simply seeking to build a family in another country.
The restrictions also extend to lesbian couples, who may need to go abroad for insemination and surrogacy services. The law places additional hurdles for these couples, making it harder for them to access assisted reproductive technologies.
Furthermore, the new law also restricts heterosexual couples from pursuing surrogacy abroad as the consequences are dire regardless of their sexual orientation.
Is This a Backlash Against Gay Rights?
Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s government has faced backlash from LGBTQ+ rights groups over the law. They argue that this is an attack on gay rights and reproductive freedom, as it directly impacts same-sex couples who may have no other options for parenthood. The law also raises questions about the balance between government regulation and personal freedoms.
Click here to read how surrogacy works for gay couples.
What Happens If You Break the Law?
The penalties for breaking Italy’s new surrogacy law are severe. Italian citizens found to be using surrogacy services abroad can face prison sentences of up to two years and hefty fines. This has led many to fear that the law will force couples to hide their surrogacy arrangements, making it more difficult for authorities to track and regulate the practice.
The fines, which could amount to €1 million, are designed to discourage people from seeking surrogacy abroad. However, it remains to be seen whether the law will be effective in curbing the practice, as international surrogacy continues to be a major draw for couples from countries where it is banned.
What Are the Alternatives for Italian Couples?
The passing of this law has left many Italian couples wondering what their alternatives are for starting a family. With surrogacy now criminalized, couples may look at other options, such as adoption or egg/sperm donation. However, both options have their challenges, and adoption laws in Italy are notoriously difficult to navigate.
Adoption in Italy
While adoption is a legal path to parenthood in Italy, it can be a lengthy and complicated process. The country has strict regulations surrounding adoption, and the wait times can be long. For same-sex couples, adoption can be particularly difficult, as they have to resort to civil lawsuits (through “adoption in particular cases”) to legally become parents.
Egg and Sperm Donation
Italy has strict laws regarding egg and sperm donation as well. Donation is allowed, but only under certain conditions. Anonymous donations are allowed and accessible to infertile heterosexual couples. However, the recipient parents and the donor-conceived child are not allowed to know the details of the donor’s identity, except where it is necessary for the child’s health.
Conclusion
The Italian Parliament’s decision to criminalize surrogacy abroad is a major turning point for Italian couples, particularly LGBT+ individuals, who were previously turning to international surrogacy as a path to parenthood. While the law is meant to protect traditional family values, it raises serious concerns about personal freedoms and reproductive rights.
However, Anavara remains committed to helping you build the family of your dreams. Whether you’re looking for answers or ready to take the next step, our team is here to support you.
For more information about surrogacy options, contact Anavara today.
References
The information provided in this blog is for educational purposes only and should not be considered as medical advice. It is not intended to replace professional medical consultation, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult with a qualified healthcare provider before making any decisions regarding your health. Read more
